If God were to take all good people to heaven, it would imply that he failed to accomplish his original purpose for the earth and that his promises regarding everlasting life on earth are not true.
فإذا رفع الله جميع الصالحين الى السماء‏ ،‏ فهل يحقِّق اذَّاك قصده للارض ويصدُق في وعده بحياة ابدية عليها ؟‏ طبعا لا .‏