text:
167 F.Supp.3d 147 (2016)
SOUNDEXCHANGE, INC. Plaintiff
v.
MUZAK, LLC Defendant.

Case 15-cv-0476-RCL.
United States District Court, District of Columbia.

Signed March 7, 2016.
Filed March 8, 2016.
Emily Lauren Chapuis, Joshua Morris Segal, Michael Brian Desanctis, Jenner & Block LLP, Washington, DC, for Plaintiff.

148*148 Brian M. Willen, Wilson Sansini Goodrich & Rosati, New York, NY, Michael R. Petrocelli, Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, San Francisco, CA, for Defendant.

MEMORANDUM OPINION

Royce C. Lamberth, United States District Judge.

Now before the Court is defendant's motion to dismiss, plaintiff's opposition, and defendant's reply. ECF Nos. 13, 18, & 21. For the reasons stated below and by separate order issued this date, defendant's motion shall be GRANTED.

I. BACKGROUND

The facts set out herein are either undisputed, or are as alleged by plaintiff. The Court, in keeping with its responsibilities under Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6) accepts as true all factual allegations set forth by plaintiff for purposes of this motion.

a. Plaintiff's role in collecting royalties under the Copyright Act

Plaintiff is a nonprofit organization, with statutory authority under, inter alia, 17 U.S.C. § 114(g) and 37 C.F.R. §§ 370, 382, and 384, as designated by the Copyright Royalty Judges. Compl., ECF No. 1, at 3; 17 U.S.C. § 801. Plaintiff filed the complaint in this case as the "sole entity designated by regulation" to "collect statutory license payments from copyright users and to distribute those payments to performing artists and copyright owners." Compl. 2. Section 114 contains various provisions making plaintiff, as the designated nonprofit agent, responsible for administrating and distributing statutory royalties and enforcing statutory licenses. The Copyright Act provides these statutory licenses as "an alternative to having every music service negotiate separate licenses with every copyright owner," under § 112(e) and (d)(2). Compl. 4. Those companies which make use of such statutory licenses pay royalties at rates set by Copyright Royalty Judge under §§ 112(e)(3) and 114(f). Accordingly, defendant (as well as other entities utilizing statutory licenses) are obligated to make payments to plaintiff under the aforementioned statutory licenses. Compl. 2.

b. The Digital Millennium Copyright Act

The Digital Millennium Copyright Act ("DMCA") established a new statutory scheme to determine royalties under Title 17 of the United States Code. Pub. L. No. 105-304, 112 Stat. 2860 (Oct. 28, 1998); 17 U.S.C. §§ 101, et seq.; Compl. 1; Def.'s Mot. Dismiss 9-11. The new standard for calculating royalty rates under the DMCA should reflect what "would have been negotiated in the marketplace between a willing buyer and a willing seller." 17 U.S.C. § 114(f)(2)(B). This is referred to as the willing buyer/willing seller standard. While the DMCA established new standards for determining royalty rates, it also created an exception for preexisting subscription services ("PSS" or "PES"). 17 U.S.C. § 114(j)(11). Defendant and two other entities were grandfathered under this exception. Compl. 6. PSS are not subject to the "willing buyer/willing seller" standard, but instead enjoy generally favorable royalty rates. Compl. 5-6. The lower PSS rates give the PSS a competitive advantage over non-PSS. Compl. 6; Pl.'s Opp. Def.'s Mot. Dismiss 11.

c. Muzak

Defendant is the provider of "a subscription-based digital music service for various satellite and cable television providers." Def.'s Mot. Dismiss 6. Defendant provided digital music service available to consumers as music channels transmitted with Dish satellite television service ("Dish") packages under the name DishCD. Compl. 149*149 1 & 9. DishCD consists generally of audio-only content transmitted on certain channels of Dish Network ("Dish"), a multichannel video programming distributor ("MVPD") under 47 U.S.C. § 522(13). Compl. 1-2. As such, defendant was one of the first entities to utilize the statutory licensing scheme provided under § 114(d)(2). Compl. 1. In 1998, under the DMCA, Congress revised the statutory licensing provisions, granting several entities status as PSS. Pub. L. No. 105-304, 112 Stat. 2860 (Oct. 28, 1998). Defendant was specifically identified as a PSS in the legislative history of the DMCA, and has continued to operate as such within the statutory definition of PSS. 17 U.S.C. § 114(j)(11); H.R. Conf. Rep. 105-796, 105th Cong., 2nd Sess., 657 (1998).

d. DMX

DMX, as "DMX (operated by TCI Music)" was also originally designated as a PSS in 1998. 17 U.S.C. § 114(j)(11); H.R. Conf. Rep. 105-796, 105th Cong., 2nd Sess., 657 (1998); Compl. 10. By 2006, DMX business and offerings had been restructured and the resultant entity no longer claimed the PSS rates. Compl. 10; Designation as a Preexisting Subscription Service, 71 Fed. Reg. 64,639-1 (Nov. 3, 2006). After 2006, DMX, or the entities offering music services under the DMX brand name, made statutory royalty payments to plaintiff under the new subscription service rate. Compl. 10. DMX began offering a new brand, SonicTap, in 2010, which provided subscription packages for DirecTV satellite television at the new subscription service rates (the willing buyer/willing seller standard) rather than the PSS rates. 17 U.S.C. § 114(f)(2)(B); Compl. 10; Pl.'s Opp. Def.'s Mot. Dismiss 13-14.

e. Acquisition of Muzak and DMX

Mood Media Corporation ("Mood") acquired Muzak in 2011. Compl. 9. In 2012, Mood also acquired DMX Holdings, Inc., which was the provider of DMX services (specifically, SonicTap on DirecTV). Compl. 10. When Mood acquired DMX, SonicTap was making royalty payments at the new subscription service rate. Compl. 10. Defendant acquired the right to provide audio-only channels to DMX's previous customers effective May 1, 2014. Compl. 10; Pl.'s Opp. Def.'s Mot. Dimiss 14. Defendant notified plaintiff of the acquisition and intent to utilize the PSS rate, then continued to make royalty payments for the services that were previously provided by DMX, specifically the SonicTap services, at the PSS rate. Compl. 10-11. Plaintiff asked defendant for clarification as to why defendant believed that these services qualified for the PSS royalty rates, to which defendant replied it was "eligible to pay royalties as a [PSS] for all of its activities..." Compl. 11. In May 2014, DMX ceased independently making royalty payments to plaintiff; at the same time defendant began making royalty payments at a higher rate. Compl. 11. Presumably, the higher payment reflects defendant making royalty payments for providing the services it began making that were previously made by DMX.

II. ANALYSIS

The parties dispute whether defendant is entitled to utilize the PSS royalty rate for certain services it provides to customers previously served by DMX Holdings, Inc.'s SonicTap. The parties do not appear to dispute the material fact recited herein. Instead, the issue appears to be one of statutory interpretation.

a. Jurisdiction and Venue

Jurisdiction is appropriate under the Copyright Act and Title 28 of the U.S. Code. 17 U.S.C. § 101, et seq.; 28 U.S.C. § 1331; 28 U.S.C. § 1338(a). The Court accepts, for the purposes of this motion, plaintiff's undisputed factual allegations 150*150 that venue is proper due to defendant's sufficient contacts with the district, as well as the allegation that a substantial part of the events giving rise to the dispute occurred within the district. Compl. 2; 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b)(1) & (b)(2).

b. Standard of Review — Motion to Dismiss under Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(6)

Defendant moves to dismiss for failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted under Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(6). In order to withstand a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim, the complaint must contain "a short and plain statement of the claim showing that the pleader is entitled to relief, in order to give the defendant fair notice of what the ... claim is and the grounds upon which it rests." Bell Atl. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544, 555, 127 S.Ct. 1955, 167 L.Ed.2d 929 (2007) (internal quotations marks and citations omitted). Further, in ruling on a motion to dismiss, the D.C. Circuit notes that the court will generally, "accept as true all of the factual allegations contained in the complaint." Atherton v. Dist. of Columbia, 567 F.3d 672, 681 (D.C.Cir.2009). This does not mean that the court must accept "threadbare recitals of a cause of action's elements, supported by mere conclusory statements." Ashcroft v. Iqbal, 556 U.S. 662, 663, 129 S.Ct. 1937, 173 L.Ed.2d 868 (2009) (citing Bell Atl. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544, 555, 127 S.Ct. 1955, 167 L.Ed.2d 929 (2007)).

c. DMCA, § 114(j)(11)

The parties disagree on whether defendant can continue to utilize the PSS royalty rate with regard to the portion of services transferred from DMX (primarily SonicTap). Compl. 9-11; Def.'s Mot. Dismiss 10.

The DMCA provides the following definition of PSS:

A "preexisting subscription service" is a service that performs sound recordings by means of noninteractive audio-only subscription digital audio transmissions, which was in existence and was making such transmissions to the public for a fee on or before July 31, 1998, and may include a limited number of sample channels representative of the subscription service that are made available on a nonsubscription basis in order to promote the subscription service.
17 U.S.C. § 114(j)(11) (2015). There are two relevant clauses in § 114(j)(11). First, "a service that performs sounds recordings by means of noninteractive audio-only subscription digital audio transmissions." The next clause that is relevant is the language, "which was in existence and was making such transmissions to the public for a fee on or before July 31, 1998." § 114(j)(11).

d. Statutory Interpretation

The parties differ in their interpretation of how § 114(j)(11) applies the grandfathering provision. Defendant contends that the plain text of the statute yields a two-part analysis to determine whether status as a PSS is granted under the DMCA; first, that the service provides sound recordings by "noninteractive audio-only" means, and second, that it has been providing "such transmissions" since July 31, 1998. Def.'s Mot. Dismiss 16 (citing § 114(j)(11)). Defendant argues that this is a disjunctive test and therefore that it can meet each criteria separately to qualify for PSS rates. Def.'s Mot. Dismiss at 11-12. Defendant argues that a plain reading of the statute reveals that the language "such transmissions" means the type of transmissions laid out in the beginning of that sentence, or "noninteractive audio-only subscription digital audio transmissions," regardless of whether provided to the same customers, or a different group of 151*151 customers. Def.'s Reply Pl.'s Opp. Def.'s Mot. Dismiss 6-8 (citing 17 U.S.C. § 114(j)(11) (2015)).

Conversely, plaintiff comprehends § 114(j)(11) to impose a conjunctive two-part requirement. Pl.'s Opp. Def.'s Mot. Dismiss, 7-8. Specifically, plaintiff alleges that the PSS royalty only applies to PSS at the time of the DMCA's enactment and only for their services provided at that same time that qualified for the PSS royalty rate. Id. In other words, "[t]o benefit from PSS rates ... a licensee had to be the same business entity that secured the statutory license prior to July 31, 1998...." Pl.'s Opp. Def.'s Mot. Dismiss 12. When it comes to "such transmissions," plaintiff interprets this phrase as requiring the PSS to be making exactly the same transmissions as it was on July 31, 1998. Pl.'s Opp. Def.'s Mot Dismiss 17. Put another way, plaintiff is interpreting the word "such" to mean "the same" or "identical" transmissions to the same set of customers. Id.

The "first step in interpreting a statute is to determine whether the language at issue has a plain and unambiguous meaning with regard to the particular dispute in the case." Robinson v. Shell Oil Co., 519 U.S. 337, 340, 117 S.Ct. 843, 136 L.Ed.2d 808 (1997). The Robinson court noted that "[o]ur inquiry must cease if the statutory language is unambiguous ...." Id. The difference between the parties comes down to whether the entity which qualified as a PSS can make the same type of transmissions contemplated by § 114(j)(11) to new customers and retain the PSS royalty rate for the additional transmissions. To determine whether Congress intended for the PSS rate to apply in this manner, the Court examines the rest of the statute.

There are other provisions in the statute that make clear Congress's intent for PSS to be able to expand their businesses in certain ways yet remain under the PSS royalty scheme. In § 114(f)(1)(C), the statute provides that a copyright owner or PSS can initiate procedures under § 114(f)(1)(A) or (B) "indicating that a new type of subscription digital audio transmission service on which sound recordings are performed is or is about to become operational..." in order to determine whether such service should fall under the PSS royalty rates as established by the Copyright Royalty Judges pursuant to § 114(f)(1)(A) or (B). Subsection 114(f)(1) thus provides a mechanism for the PSS to notify the appropriate authority that there is a new type of service and essentially obtain a ruling about whether transmissions on this new type of service may also fall under the PSS rate. This provision, therefore, is clear evidence that Congress did at least intend for a PSS to be able to provide the some "new type" of service and still utilize the PSS royalty rate.

e. Legislative History and the 2006 Decision

Though the Court need rely on the legislative history of § 114, nor look to the Register of Copyrights' 2006 decision, it sees its ruling today as consistent with the Register's analysis as well as § 114's legislative history. H.R. Conf. Rep. 105-796, 105th Cong., 2nd Sess. (1998); U.S. Copyright Office, Designation as a Preexisting Subscription Service, 71 Fed. Reg. 64,639-1 1 (Nov. 3, 2006). To wit, the conference report describes a PSS as "making transmissions to the public on or before July 31, 1998, and which is making transmissions similar in character to such transmissions made on or before July 31, 1998." H.R. Conf. Rep. 105-796 at 89 (1998) (emphasis added). Next, the report notes:

... the conferee's objective was to limit the grandfather to their existing services in the same transmission medium 152*152 and to any new services in a new transmission medium where only transmissions similar to their existing service are provided. Thus, if a cable subscription music service making transmissions on July 31, 1998, were to offer the same music service through the Internet, then such Internet service would be considered part of a preexisting subscription service.
Id. The operative language here is "to any new services in a new transmission medium where only transmissions similar to their existing service are provided." Id. Immediately following that, the report provides:

If, however, a subscription service making transmissions on July 31, 1998, were to offer a new service either in the same or new transmission medium by taking advantages of the capabilities of that medium, such new service would not qualify as a preexisting subscription service. For example, a service that offers video programming, such as advertising or other content, would not qualify as a preexisting service, provided that the video programming is not merely information about the service itself, the sound recordings being transmitted, the featured artists, composers or songwriters, or an advertisement to purchase the sound recording transmitted.
Id. The operative language in this portion of the report appears to be "new service either in the same or new transmission medium by taking advantages of the capabilities of that medium...." Id.

Likewise, in 2006, the Register of Copyrights reached a decision in which it concluded the term "preexisting subscription service" is best understood as "referring to the business entity identified as the [PSS]," rather than the program offerings made on a subscription basis to the public. 71 Fed. Reg. at 64646. Although the Register's decision also relies upon principles of statutory construction not indulged here, the Register's principle reasoning remains in accordance with this opinion.

III. CONCLUSION

In light of the Court's analysis defendant's motion shall be GRANTED by a separate Order issued this date.

text: F

text: Supp

text: d

text: SOUNDEXCHANGE

text: INC

text: Plaintiff

text: v

text: MUZAK

text: LLC

text: Defendant

text: Case

text: cv

text: RCL

text: United

text: States

text: District

text: Court

text: District

text: of

text: Columbia

text: Signed

text: March

text: Filed

text: March

text: Emily

text: Lauren

text: Chapuis

text: Joshua

text: Morris

text: Segal

text: Michael

text: Brian

text: Desanctis

text: Jenner

text: Block

text: LLP

text: Washington

text: DC

text: for

text: Plaintiff

text: Brian

text: M

text: Willen

text: Wilson

text: Sansini

text: Goodrich

text: Rosati

text: New

text: York

text: NY

text: Michael

text: R

text: Petrocelli

text: Wilson

text: Sonsini

text: Goodrich

text: Rosati

text: San

text: Francisco

text: CA

text: for

text: Defendant

text: MEMORANDUM

text: OPINION

text: Royce

text: C

text: Lamberth

text: United

text: States

text: District

text: Judge

text: Now

text: before

text: the

text: Court

text: is

text: defendant

text: s

text: motion

text: to

text: dismiss

text: plaintiff

text: s

text: opposition

text: and

text: defendant

text: s

text: reply

text: ECF

text: Nos

text: For

text: the

text: reasons

text: stated

text: below

text: and

text: by

text: separate

text: order

text: issued

text: this

text: date

text: defendant

text: s

text: motion

text: shall

text: be

text: GRANTED

text: I

text: BACKGROUND

text: The

text: facts

text: set

text: out

text: herein

text: are

text: either

text: undisputed

text: or

text: are

text: as

text: alleged

text: by

text: plaintiff

text: The

text: Court

text: in

text: keeping

text: with

text: its

text: responsibilities

text: under

text: Federal

text: Rules

text: of

text: Civil

text: Procedure

text: b

text: accepts

text: as

text: true

text: all

text: factual

text: allegations

text: set

text: forth

text: by

text: plaintiff

text: for

text: purposes

text: of

text: this

text: motion

text: a

text: Plaintiff

text: s

text: role

text: in

text: collecting

text: royalties

text: under

text: the

text: Copyright

text: Act

text: Plaintiff

text: is

text: a

text: nonprofit

text: organization

text: with

text: statutory

text: authority

text: under

text: inter

text: alia

text: U

text: S

text: C

text: g

text: and

text: C

text: F

text: R

text: and

text: as

text: designated

text: by

text: the

text: Copyright

text: Royalty

text: Judges

text: Compl

text: ECF

text: No

text: at

text: U

text: S

text: C

text: Plaintiff

text: filed

text: the

text: complaint

text: in

text: this

text: case

text: as

text: the

text: sole

text: entity

text: designated

text: by

text: regulation

text: to

text: collect

text: statutory

text: license

text: payments

text: from

text: copyright

text: users

text: and

text: to

text: distribute

text: those

text: payments

text: to

text: performing

text: artists

text: and

text: copyright

text: owners

text: Compl

text: Section

text: contains

text: various

text: provisions

text: making

text: plaintiff

text: as

text: the

text: designated

text: nonprofit

text: agent

text: responsible

text: for

text: administrating

text: and

text: distributing

text: statutory

text: royalties

text: and

text: enforcing

text: statutory

text: licenses

text: The

text: Copyright

text: Act

text: provides

text: these

text: statutory

text: licenses

text: as

text: an

text: alternative

text: to

text: having

text: every

text: music

text: service

text: negotiate

text: separate

text: licenses

text: with

text: every

text: copyright

text: owner

text: under

text: e

text: and

text: d

text: Compl

text: Those

text: companies

text: which

text: make

text: use

text: of

text: such

text: statutory

text: licenses

text: pay

text: royalties

text: at

text: rates

text: set

text: by

text: Copyright

text: Royalty

text: Judge

text: under

text: e

text: and

text: f

text: Accordingly

text: defendant

text: as

text: well

text: as

text: other

text: entities

text: utilizing

text: statutory

text: licenses

text: are

text: obligated

text: to

text: make

text: payments

text: to

text: plaintiff

text: under

text: the

text: aforementioned

text: statutory

text: licenses

text: Compl

text: b

text: The

text: Digital

text: Millennium

text: Copyright

text: Act

text: The

text: Digital

text: Millennium

text: Copyright

text: Act

text: DMCA

text: established

text: a

text: new

text: statutory

text: scheme

text: to

text: determine

text: royalties

text: under

text: Title

text: of

text: the

text: United

text: States

text: Code

text: Pub

text: L

text: No

text: Stat

text: Oct

text: U

text: S

text: C

text: et

text: seq

text: Compl

text: Def

text: s

text: Mot

text: Dismiss

text: The

text: new

text: standard

text: for

text: calculating

text: royalty

text: rates

text: under

text: the

text: DMCA

text: should

text: reflect

text: what

text: would

text: have

text: been

text: negotiated

text: in

text: the

text: marketplace

text: between

text: a

text: willing

text: buyer

text: and

text: a

text: willing

text: seller

text: U

text: S

text: C

text: f

text: B

text: This

text: is

text: referred

text: to

text: as

text: the

text: willing

text: buyer

text: willing

text: seller

text: standard

text: While

text: the

text: DMCA

text: established

text: new

text: standards

text: for

text: determining

text: royalty

text: rates

text: it

text: also

text: created

text: an

text: exception

text: for

text: preexisting

text: subscription

text: services

text: PSS

text: or

text: PES

text: U

text: S

text: C

text: j

text: Defendant

text: and

text: two

text: other

text: entities

text: were

text: grandfathered

text: under

text: this

text: exception

text: Compl

text: PSS

text: are

text: not

text: subject

text: to

text: the

text: willing

text: buyer

text: willing

text: seller

text: standard

text: but

text: instead

text: enjoy

text: generally

text: favorable

text: royalty

text: rates

text: Compl

text: The

text: lower

text: PSS

text: rates

text: give

text: the

text: PSS

text: a

text: competitive

text: advantage

text: over

text: non

text: PSS

text: Compl

text: Pl

text: s

text: Opp

text: Def

text: s

text: Mot

text: Dismiss

text: c

text: Muzak

text: Defendant

text: is

text: the

text: provider

text: of

text: a

text: subscription

text: based

text: digital

text: music

text: service

text: for

text: various

text: satellite

text: and

text: cable

text: television

text: providers

text: Def

text: s

text: Mot

text: Dismiss

text: Defendant

text: provided

text: digital

text: music

text: service

text: available

text: to

text: consumers

text: as

text: music

text: channels

text: transmitted

text: with

text: Dish

text: satellite

text: television

text: service

text: Dish

text: packages

text: under

text: the

text: name

text: DishCD

text: Compl

text: DishCD

text: consists

text: generally

text: of

text: audio

text: only

text: content

text: transmitted

text: on

text: certain

text: channels

text: of

text: Dish

text: Network

text: Dish

text: a

text: multichannel

text: video

text: programming

text: distributor

text: MVPD

text: under

text: U

text: S

text: C

text: Compl

text: As

text: such

text: defendant

text: was

text: one

text: of

text: the

text: first

text: entities

text: to

text: utilize

text: the

text: statutory

text: licensing

text: scheme

text: provided

text: under

text: d

text: Compl

text: In

text: under

text: the

text: DMCA

text: Congress

text: revised

text: the

text: statutory

text: licensing

text: provisions

text: granting

text: several

text: entities

text: status

text: as

text: PSS

text: Pub

text: L

text: No

text: Stat

text: Oct

text: Defendant

text: was

text: specifically

text: identified

text: as

text: a

text: PSS

text: in

text: the

text: legislative

text: history

text: of

text: the

text: DMCA

text: and

text: has

text: continued

text: to

text: operate

text: as

text: such

text: within

text: the

text: statutory

text: definition

text: of

text: PSS

text: U

text: S

text: C

text: j

text: H

text: R

text: Conf

text: Rep

text: th

text: Cong

text: nd

text: Sess

text: d

text: DMX

text: DMX

text: as

text: DMX

text: operated

text: by

text: TCI

text: Music

text: was

text: also

text: originally

text: designated

text: as

text: a

text: PSS

text: in

text: U

text: S

text: C

text: j

text: H

text: R

text: Conf

text: Rep

text: th

text: Cong

text: nd

text: Sess

text: Compl

text: By

text: DMX

text: business

text: and

text: offerings

text: had

text: been

text: restructured

text: and

text: the

text: resultant

text: entity

text: no

text: longer

text: claimed

text: the

text: PSS

text: rates

text: Compl

text: Designation

text: as

text: a

text: Preexisting

text: Subscription

text: Service

text: Fed

text: Reg

text: Nov

text: After

text: DMX

text: or

text: the

text: entities

text: offering

text: music

text: services

text: under

text: the

text: DMX

text: brand

text: name

text: made

text: statutory

text: royalty

text: payments

text: to

text: plaintiff

text: under

text: the

text: new

text: subscription

text: service

text: rate

text: Compl

text: DMX

text: began

text: offering

text: a

text: new

text: brand

text: SonicTap

text: in

text: which

text: provided

text: subscription

text: packages

text: for

text: DirecTV

text: satellite

text: television

text: at

text: the

text: new

text: subscription

text: service

text: rates

text: the

text: willing

text: buyer

text: willing

text: seller

text: standard

text: rather

text: than

text: the

text: PSS

text: rates

text: U

text: S

text: C

text: f

text: B

text: Compl

text: Pl

text: s

text: Opp

text: Def

text: s

text: Mot

text: Dismiss

text: e

text: Acquisition

text: of

text: Muzak

text: and

text: DMX

text: Mood

text: Media

text: Corporation

text: Mood

text: acquired

text: Muzak

text: in

text: Compl

text: In

text: Mood

text: also

text: acquired

text: DMX

text: Holdings

text: Inc

text: which

text: was

text: the

text: provider

text: of

text: DMX

text: services

text: specifically

text: SonicTap

text: on

text: DirecTV

text: Compl

text: When

text: Mood

text: acquired

text: DMX

text: SonicTap

text: was

text: making

text: royalty

text: payments

text: at

text: the

text: new

text: subscription

text: service

text: rate

text: Compl

text: Defendant

text: acquired

text: the

text: right

text: to

text: provide

text: audio

text: only

text: channels

text: to

text: DMX

text: s

text: previous

text: customers

text: effective

text: May

text: Compl

text: Pl

text: s

text: Opp

text: Def

text: s

text: Mot

text: Dimiss

text: Defendant

text: notified

text: plaintiff

text: of

text: the

text: acquisition

text: and

text: intent

text: to

text: utilize

text: the

text: PSS

text: rate

text: then

text: continued

text: to

text: make

text: royalty

text: payments

text: for

text: the

text: services

text: that

text: were

text: previously

text: provided

text: by

text: DMX

text: specifically

text: the

text: SonicTap

text: services

text: at

text: the

text: PSS

text: rate

text: Compl

text: Plaintiff

text: asked

text: defendant

text: for

text: clarification

text: as

text: to

text: why

text: defendant

text: believed

text: that

text: these

text: services

text: qualified

text: for

text: the

text: PSS

text: royalty

text: rates

text: to

text: which

text: defendant

text: replied

text: it

text: was

text: eligible

text: to

text: pay

text: royalties

text: as

text: a

text: PSS

text: for

text: all

text: of

text: its

text: activities

text: Compl

text: In

text: May

text: DMX

text: ceased

text: independently

text: making

text: royalty

text: payments

text: to

text: plaintiff

text: at

text: the

text: same

text: time

text: defendant

text: began

text: making

text: royalty

text: payments

text: at

text: a

text: higher

text: rate

text: Compl

text: Presumably

text: the

text: higher

text: payment

text: reflects

text: defendant

text: making

text: royalty

text: payments

text: for

text: providing

text: the

text: services

text: it

text: began

text: making

text: that

text: were

text: previously

text: made

text: by

text: DMX

text: II

text: ANALYSIS

text: The

text: parties

text: dispute

text: whether

text: defendant

text: is

text: entitled

text: to

text: utilize

text: the

text: PSS

text: royalty

text: rate

text: for

text: certain

text: services

text: it

text: provides

text: to

text: customers

text: previously

text: served

text: by

text: DMX

text: Holdings

text: Inc

text: s

text: SonicTap

text: The

text: parties

text: do

text: not

text: appear

text: to

text: dispute

text: the

text: material

text: fact

text: recited

text: herein

text: Instead

text: the

text: issue

text: appears

text: to

text: be

text: one

text: of

text: statutory

text: interpretation

text: a

text: Jurisdiction

text: and

text: Venue

text: Jurisdiction

text: is

text: appropriate

text: under

text: the

text: Copyright

text: Act

text: and

text: Title

text: of

text: the

text: U

text: S

text: Code

text: U

text: S

text: C

text: et

text: seq

text: U

text: S

text: C

text: U

text: S

text: C

text: a

text: The

text: Court

text: accepts

text: for

text: the

text: purposes

text: of

text: this

text: motion

text: plaintiff

text: s

text: undisputed

text: factual

text: allegations

text: that

text: venue

text: is

text: proper

text: due

text: to

text: defendant

text: s

text: sufficient

text: contacts

text: with

text: the

text: district

text: as

text: well

text: as

text: the

text: allegation

text: that

text: a

text: substantial

text: part

text: of

text: the

text: events

text: giving

text: rise

text: to

text: the

text: dispute

text: occurred

text: within

text: the

text: district

text: Compl

text: U

text: S

text: C

text: b

text: b

text: b

text: Standard

text: of

text: Review

text: Motion

text: to

text: Dismiss

text: under

text: Fed

text: R

text: Civ

text: P

text: b

text: Defendant

text: moves

text: to

text: dismiss

text: for

text: failure

text: to

text: state

text: a

text: claim

text: upon

text: which

text: relief

text: can

text: be

text: granted

text: under

text: Fed

text: R

text: Civ

text: P

text: b

text: In

text: order

text: to

text: withstand

text: a

text: motion

text: to

text: dismiss

text: for

text: failure

text: to

text: state

text: a

text: claim

text: the

text: complaint

text: must

text: contain

text: a

text: short

text: and

text: plain

text: statement

text: of

text: the

text: claim

text: showing

text: that

text: the

text: pleader

text: is

text: entitled

text: to

text: relief

text: in

text: order

text: to

text: give

text: the

text: defendant

text: fair

text: notice

text: of

text: what

text: the

text: claim

text: is

text: and

text: the

text: grounds

text: upon

text: which

text: it

text: rests

text: Bell

text: Atl

text: Corp

text: v

text: Twombly

text: U

text: S

text: S

text: Ct

text: L

text: Ed

text: d

text: internal

text: quotations

text: marks

text: and

text: citations

text: omitted

text: Further

text: in

text: ruling

text: on

text: a

text: motion

text: to

text: dismiss

text: the

text: D

text: C

text: Circuit

text: notes

text: that

text: the

text: court

text: will

text: generally

text: accept

text: as

text: true

text: all

text: of

text: the

text: factual

text: allegations

text: contained

text: in

text: the

text: complaint

text: Atherton

text: v

text: Dist

text: of

text: Columbia

text: F

text: d

text: D

text: C

text: Cir

text: This

text: does

text: not

text: mean

text: that

text: the

text: court

text: must

text: accept

text: threadbare

text: recitals

text: of

text: a

text: cause

text: of

text: action

text: s

text: elements

text: supported

text: by

text: mere

text: conclusory

text: statements

text: Ashcroft

text: v

text: Iqbal

text: U

text: S

text: S

text: Ct

text: L

text: Ed

text: d

text: citing

text: Bell

text: Atl

text: Corp

text: v

text: Twombly

text: U

text: S

text: S

text: Ct

text: L

text: Ed

text: d

text: c

text: DMCA

text: j

text: The

text: parties

text: disagree

text: on

text: whether

text: defendant

text: can

text: continue

text: to

text: utilize

text: the

text: PSS

text: royalty

text: rate

text: with

text: regard

text: to

text: the

text: portion

text: of

text: services

text: transferred

text: from

text: DMX

text: primarily

text: SonicTap

text: Compl

text: Def

text: s

text: Mot

text: Dismiss

text: The

text: DMCA

text: provides

text: the

text: following

text: definition

text: of

text: PSS

text: A

text: preexisting

text: subscription

text: service

text: is

text: a

text: service

text: that

text: performs

text: sound

text: recordings

text: by

text: means

text: of

text: noninteractive

text: audio

text: only

text: subscription

text: digital

text: audio

text: transmissions

text: which

text: was

text: in

text: existence

text: and

text: was

text: making

text: such

text: transmissions

text: to

text: the

text: public

text: for

text: a

text: fee

text: on

text: or

text: before

text: July

text: and

text: may

text: include

text: a

text: limited

text: number

text: of

text: sample

text: channels

text: representative

text: of

text: the

text: subscription

text: service

text: that

text: are

text: made

text: available

text: on

text: a

text: nonsubscription

text: basis

text: in

text: order

text: to

text: promote

text: the

text: subscription

text: service

text: U

text: S

text: C

text: j

text: There

text: are

text: two

text: relevant

text: clauses

text: in

text: j

text: First

text: a

text: service

text: that

text: performs

text: sounds

text: recordings

text: by

text: means

text: of

text: noninteractive

text: audio

text: only

text: subscription

text: digital

text: audio

text: transmissions

text: The

text: next

text: clause

text: that

text: is

text: relevant

text: is

text: the

text: language

text: which

text: was

text: in

text: existence

text: and

text: was

text: making

text: such

text: transmissions

text: to

text: the

text: public

text: for

text: a

text: fee

text: on

text: or

text: before

text: July

text: j

text: d

text: Statutory

text: Interpretation

text: The

text: parties

text: differ

text: in

text: their

text: interpretation

text: of

text: how

text: j

text: applies

text: the

text: grandfathering

text: provision

text: Defendant

text: contends

text: that

text: the

text: plain

text: text

text: of

text: the

text: statute

text: yields

text: a

text: two

text: part

text: analysis

text: to

text: determine

text: whether

text: status

text: as

text: a

text: PSS

text: is

text: granted

text: under

text: the

text: DMCA

text: first

text: that

text: the

text: service

text: provides

text: sound

text: recordings

text: by

text: noninteractive

text: audio

text: only

text: means

text: and

text: second

text: that

text: it

text: has

text: been

text: providing

text: such

text: transmissions

text: since

text: July

text: Def

text: s

text: Mot

text: Dismiss

text: citing

text: j

text: Defendant

text: argues

text: that

text: this

text: is

text: a

text: disjunctive

text: test

text: and

text: therefore

text: that

text: it

text: can

text: meet

text: each

text: criteria

text: separately

text: to

text: qualify

text: for

text: PSS

text: rates

text: Def

text: s

text: Mot

text: Dismiss

text: at

text: Defendant

text: argues

text: that

text: a

text: plain

text: reading

text: of

text: the

text: statute

text: reveals

text: that

text: the

text: language

text: such

text: transmissions

text: means

text: the

text: type

text: of

text: transmissions

text: laid

text: out

text: in

text: the

text: beginning

text: of

text: that

text: sentence

text: or

text: noninteractive

text: audio

text: only

text: subscription

text: digital

text: audio

text: transmissions

text: regardless

text: of

text: whether

text: provided

text: to

text: the

text: same

text: customers

text: or

text: a

text: different

text: group

text: of

text: customers

text: Def

text: s

text: Reply

text: Pl

text: s

text: Opp

text: Def

text: s

text: Mot

text: Dismiss

text: citing

text: U

text: S

text: C

text: j

text: Conversely

text: plaintiff

text: comprehends

text: j

text: to

text: impose

text: a

text: conjunctive

text: two

text: part

text: requirement

text: Pl

text: s

text: Opp

text: Def

text: s

text: Mot

text: Dismiss

text: Specifically

text: plaintiff

text: alleges

text: that

text: the

text: PSS

text: royalty

text: only

text: applies

text: to

text: PSS

text: at

text: the

text: time

text: of

text: the

text: DMCA

text: s

text: enactment

text: and

text: only

text: for

text: their

text: services

text: provided

text: at

text: that

text: same

text: time

text: that

text: qualified

text: for

text: the

text: PSS

text: royalty

text: rate

text: Id

text: In

text: other

text: words

text: t

text: o

text: benefit

text: from

text: PSS

text: rates

text: a

text: licensee

text: had

text: to

text: be

text: the

text: same

text: business

text: entity

text: that

text: secured

text: the

text: statutory

text: license

text: prior

text: to

text: July

text: Pl

text: s

text: Opp

text: Def

text: s

text: Mot

text: Dismiss

text: When

text: it

text: comes

text: to

text: such

text: transmissions

text: plaintiff

text: interprets

text: this

text: phrase

text: as

text: requiring

text: the

text: PSS

text: to

text: be

text: making

text: exactly

text: the

text: same

text: transmissions

text: as

text: it

text: was

text: on

text: July

text: Pl

text: s

text: Opp

text: Def

text: s

text: Mot

text: Dismiss

text: Put

text: another

text: way

text: plaintiff

text: is

text: interpreting

text: the

text: word

text: such

text: to

text: mean

text: the

text: same

text: or

text: identical

text: transmissions

text: to

text: the

text: same

text: set

text: of

text: customers

text: Id

text: The

text: first

text: step

text: in

text: interpreting

text: a

text: statute

text: is

text: to

text: determine

text: whether

text: the

text: language

text: at

text: issue

text: has

text: a

text: plain

text: and

text: unambiguous

text: meaning

text: with

text: regard

text: to

text: the

text: particular

text: dispute

text: in

text: the

text: case

text: Robinson

text: v

text: Shell

text: Oil

text: Co

text: U

text: S

text: S

text: Ct

text: L

text: Ed

text: d

text: The

text: Robinson

text: court

text: noted

text: that

text: o

text: ur

text: inquiry

text: must

text: cease

text: if

text: the

text: statutory

text: language

text: is

text: unambiguous

text: Id

text: The

text: difference

text: between

text: the

text: parties

text: comes

text: down

text: to

text: whether

text: the

text: entity

text: which

text: qualified

text: as

text: a

text: PSS

text: can

text: make

text: the

text: same

text: type

text: of

text: transmissions

text: contemplated

text: by

text: j

text: to

text: new

text: customers

text: and

text: retain

text: the

text: PSS

text: royalty

text: rate

text: for

text: the

text: additional

text: transmissions

text: To

text: determine

text: whether

text: Congress

text: intended

text: for

text: the

text: PSS

text: rate

text: to

text: apply

text: in

text: this

text: manner

text: the

text: Court

text: examines

text: the

text: rest

text: of

text: the

text: statute

text: There

text: are

text: other

text: provisions

text: in

text: the

text: statute

text: that

text: make

text: clear

text: Congress

text: s

text: intent

text: for

text: PSS

text: to

text: be

text: able

text: to

text: expand

text: their

text: businesses

text: in

text: certain

text: ways

text: yet

text: remain

text: under

text: the

text: PSS

text: royalty

text: scheme

text: In

text: f

text: C

text: the

text: statute

text: provides

text: that

text: a

text: copyright

text: owner

text: or

text: PSS

text: can

text: initiate

text: procedures

text: under

text: f

text: A

text: or

text: B

text: indicating

text: that

text: a

text: new

text: type

text: of

text: subscription

text: digital

text: audio

text: transmission

text: service

text: on

text: which

text: sound

text: recordings

text: are

text: performed

text: is

text: or

text: is

text: about

text: to

text: become

text: operational

text: in

text: order

text: to

text: determine

text: whether

text: such

text: service

text: should

text: fall

text: under

text: the

text: PSS

text: royalty

text: rates

text: as

text: established

text: by

text: the

text: Copyright

text: Royalty

text: Judges

text: pursuant

text: to

text: f

text: A

text: or

text: B

text: Subsection

text: f

text: thus

text: provides

text: a

text: mechanism

text: for

text: the

text: PSS

text: to

text: notify

text: the

text: appropriate

text: authority

text: that

text: there

text: is

text: a

text: new

text: type

text: of

text: service

text: and

text: essentially

text: obtain

text: a

text: ruling

text: about

text: whether

text: transmissions

text: on

text: this

text: new

text: type

text: of

text: service

text: may

text: also

text: fall

text: under

text: the

text: PSS

text: rate

text: This

text: provision

text: therefore

text: is

text: clear

text: evidence

text: that

text: Congress

text: did

text: at

text: least

text: intend

text: for

text: a

text: PSS

text: to

text: be

text: able

text: to

text: provide

text: the

text: some

text: new

text: type

text: of

text: service

text: and

text: still

text: utilize

text: the

text: PSS

text: royalty

text: rate

text: e

text: Legislative

text: History

text: and

text: the

text: Decision

text: Though

text: the

text: Court

text: need

text: rely

text: on

text: the

text: legislative

text: history

text: of

text: nor

text: look

text: to

text: the

text: Register

text: of

text: Copyrights

text: decision

text: it

text: sees

text: its

text: ruling

text: today

text: as

text: consistent

text: with

text: the

text: Register

text: s

text: analysis

text: as

text: well

text: as

text: s

text: legislative

text: history

text: H

text: R

text: Conf

text: Rep

text: th

text: Cong

text: nd

text: Sess

text: U

text: S

text: Copyright

text: Office

text: Designation

text: as

text: a

text: Preexisting

text: Subscription

text: Service

text: Fed

text: Reg

text: Nov

text: To

text: wit

text: the

text: conference

text: report

text: describes

text: a

text: PSS

text: as

text: making

text: transmissions

text: to

text: the

text: public

text: on

text: or

text: before

text: July

text: and

text: which

text: is

text: making

text: transmissions

text: similar

text: in

text: character

text: to

text: such

text: transmissions

text: made

text: on

text: or

text: before

text: July

text: H

text: R

text: Conf

text: Rep

text: at

text: emphasis

text: added

text: Next

text: the

text: report

text: notes

text: the

text: conferee

text: s

text: objective

text: was

text: to

text: limit

text: the

text: grandfather

text: to

text: their

text: existing

text: services

text: in

text: the

text: same

text: transmission

text: medium

text: and

text: to

text: any

text: new

text: services

text: in

text: a

text: new

text: transmission

text: medium

text: where

text: only

text: transmissions

text: similar

text: to

text: their

text: existing

text: service

text: are

text: provided

text: Thus

text: if

text: a

text: cable

text: subscription

text: music

text: service

text: making

text: transmissions

text: on

text: July

text: were

text: to

text: offer

text: the

text: same

text: music

text: service

text: through

text: the

text: Internet

text: then

text: such

text: Internet

text: service

text: would

text: be

text: considered

text: part

text: of

text: a

text: preexisting

text: subscription

text: service

text: Id

text: The

text: operative

text: language

text: here

text: is

text: to

text: any

text: new

text: services

text: in

text: a

text: new

text: transmission

text: medium

text: where

text: only

text: transmissions

text: similar

text: to

text: their

text: existing

text: service

text: are

text: provided

text: Id

text: Immediately

text: following

text: that

text: the

text: report

text: provides

text: If

text: however

text: a

text: subscription

text: service

text: making

text: transmissions

text: on

text: July

text: were

text: to

text: offer

text: a

text: new

text: service

text: either

text: in

text: the

text: same

text: or

text: new

text: transmission

text: medium

text: by

text: taking

text: advantages

text: of

text: the

text: capabilities

text: of

text: that

text: medium

text: such

text: new

text: service

text: would

text: not

text: qualify

text: as

text: a

text: preexisting

text: subscription

text: service

text: For

text: example

text: a

text: service

text: that

text: offers

text: video

text: programming

text: such

text: as

text: advertising

text: or

text: other

text: content

text: would

text: not

text: qualify

text: as

text: a

text: preexisting

text: service

text: provided

text: that

text: the

text: video

text: programming

text: is

text: not

text: merely

text: information

text: about

text: the

text: service

text: itself

text: the

text: sound

text: recordings

text: being

text: transmitted

text: the

text: featured

text: artists

text: composers

text: or

text: songwriters

text: or

text: an

text: advertisement

text: to

text: purchase

text: the

text: sound

text: recording

text: transmitted

text: Id

text: The

text: operative

text: language

text: in

text: this

text: portion

text: of

text: the

text: report

text: appears

text: to

text: be

text: new

text: service

text: either

text: in

text: the

text: same

text: or

text: new

text: transmission

text: medium

text: by

text: taking

text: advantages

text: of

text: the

text: capabilities

text: of

text: that

text: medium

text: Id

text: Likewise

text: in

text: the

text: Register

text: of

text: Copyrights

text: reached

text: a

text: decision

text: in

text: which

text: it

text: concluded

text: the

text: term

text: preexisting

text: subscription

text: service

text: is

text: best

text: understood

text: as

text: referring

text: to

text: the

text: business

text: entity

text: identified

text: as

text: the

text: PSS

text: rather

text: than

text: the

text: program

text: offerings

text: made

text: on

text: a

text: subscription

text: basis

text: to

text: the

text: public

text: Fed

text: Reg

text: at

text: Although

text: the

text: Register

text: s

text: decision

text: also

text: relies

text: upon

text: principles

text: of

text: statutory

text: construction

text: not

text: indulged

text: here

text: the

text: Register

text: s

text: principle

text: reasoning

text: remains

text: in

text: accordance

text: with

text: this

text: opinion

text: III

text: CONCLUSION

text: In

text: light

text: of

text: the

text: Court

text: s

text: analysis

text: defendant

text: s

text: motion

text: shall

text: be

text: GRANTED

text: by

text: a

text: separate

text: Order

text: issued

text: this

text: date